|How do ACL tears occur?
Dr. Souryal: The most common mechanism of injury is non-contact and caused by cutting. You're running along, you plant to change direction, and your knee buckles. The next most common is a contact injury such as being clipped from behind in football and hockey. A skier can also tear an ACL when the ski catches awkwardly in the snow or the carving of the ski twists the leg.
Are certain athletes predisposed to the injury?
Dr. Souryal: My study was the first to describe the link between bony anatomy and ACL tears and to describe the way of measuring it. We found that a certain segment of the population has a bone structure that predisposes them to an ACL tear. The ACL and posterior cruciate ligament (PCL) live in a tunnel at the end of your thigh bone. If that tunnel is very narrow (which you can detect by X-ray), then there's no room for the ACL to maneuver in cutting activity, and those people are at 26 times more risk of tearing an ACL.
In 1992, we took X-rays of 1,000 high school athletes' knees and followed them for the next two years. Whenever a player went down with an ACL injury, we looked at his notch. And it was phenomenal: The kids who were blowing out their ACLs all had those narrow notches. We stopped the study early because the numbers were so dramatic. I'm sure that there are a lot of factors that go into ACL injuries -- the notch is just one of them -- and the biggest question right now is, what lives inside the narrow notch? Does a small ACL live in a narrow notch and tears because it's never had the room to grow properly? Or does a normal-sized ACL live in the small notch and ruptures because it doesn't have the room? We don't have answers because we're not doing surgery on uninjured people and measuring their ACLs.
As a next phase, we're waiting for MRIs to get a bit clearer to allow us to measure the normal ACLs in the notches. Maybe in the next couple of years, we'll be able to answer the question. If it is a normal-sized ACL in the notch, then maybe we can go in there surgically and widen the notch, and perhaps save that person from an ACL rupture. But if it's an underdeveloped ACL in that narrow notch, you can widen the notch all day long and you're not going to fix it. Once we get this question answered, maybe we can do something about people with the predisposition.
In '92, we found that girls have proportionally narrower notches than boys. Does that have anything to do with the fact that ACL injuries are epidemic among females? I don't know, but I certainly do think that it's one factor. Other factors have to do with muscle development and neuromuscular coordination, because the boys are encouraged to be active athletically almost from birth. They may develop better neuromuscular coordination and therefore are somewhat protected as they get into high school and college. Girls are not necessarily directed into athletics early in life, and as they become more athletically active in their teens, they may not have the neuromuscular coordination that boys have. The bottom line is that nobody knows for sure. But there's definitely a higher incidence of ACL ruptures in female athletes than in male athletes.
How is a torn ACL diagnosed?
Dr. Souryal: By medical history, examination, and nowadays MRI scans. History and examination in most cases are sufficient. MRI scans are only indicated when you really cannot quite distinguish whether it's torn or not. We fans have been programmed through following the NFL, NBA and other sports that when an athlete has an injury, he gets an MRI. In the case of ACL tears, it's nice to get an MRI, but it's not mandatory.
Lachman's test and the pivot shift test are used. Both are about 90 percent diagnostic. Lachman's test like a drawer test, but instead of the knee being bent 90 degrees, it's just slightly bent, and you attempt to pull the tibia forward with one hand while holding the thigh just above the knee with the other hand. If the ACL is intact, the tibia doesn't come forward. If the ACL is torn, it keeps coming. That test is very diagnostic and conclusive when performed by an expert.
How are ACL tears treated?
Dr. Souryal: The goal of treatment is to never let the knee go out of place again. When you tear your ACL, by definition the knee buckled. Every time that happens, it can do cartilage damage, which is bad from a long-term perspective. Cartilage is there to protect you from arthritis. If your knee is constantly giving out, you're slowly chewing away pieces of the cartilage, and that can led to early arthritis. If you can keep your knee from going out again by giving up cutting sports and wearing a brace, then you've accomplished your goal.
For most people, especially young athletic ones, the only way to achieve that goal is through surgery, which is almost exclusively arthroscopic these days. You substitute for the ACL with another structure. Forty years ago, surgeons made an attempt at repairing torn ACLs, but those attempts failed, because the ligament wouldn't hold a stitch. It looks very much like fiber-optic cable or the end of a mop when you cut it across. Repairs didn't do well, so the treatment evolved into substitution. The substitute is usually a portion of the patellar tendon, which is located right in front of the ACL. The patellar tendon spans from the tip of the kneecap to the tibia.
Back in the '50s, surgeons were taking a portion of that and substituting it for the ACL, but because they couldn't see inside the knee, they were not putting it in the correct spot. Back then, they were making these huge incisions, just so they could have access to that tunnel. They were just guessing where to put that substitute ligament, and the results were usually poor. The best cases were 60 percent success rate, which is why this injury was so catastrophic. Nowadays, with arthroscopy, you can see to the millimeter where to put the substitute; hence the results are about a 98 percent return to sports. It's a far more exact procedure now.
ACL surgery is extremely technical. A millimeter difference here or there can have a huge impact on the result. The procedure is something that needs to be performed by an experienced sports orthopedist -- someone who performs the surgery two or three times a week rather than two or three times a year, someone's who's familiar with the injury, its mechanism, and the demands when you return.
How long is it usually before the injured athlete can return to his sport?
Dr. Souryal: Six months is the benchmark. Some physicians say nine; some say a year.
Can ACL tears be prevented?
Dr. Souryal: That's the $64,000 question. These injuries are so rampant. There's not a good way to prevent them. We can make some recommendations: Be sure you stretch before, during and after an activity, and get those hamstrings, quadriceps and muscle-tendon units flexible so they can absorb shock. Strength and endurance training is helpful. Most physicians recommend cross-training, because you not only develop the pure strength component but also the endurance component. That will help you in the fourth quarter of a basketball game or the second half of a soccer game. Use common sense: When you get extremely tired and your legs feel like lead pipes, that is not the time to attempt a 360 dunk. Muscles are wonderful shock absorbers. There's split-second timing that's required for a plant and a cut, and a jump and a landing, where the muscles can absorb that shock. When you're fatigued, that split-second timing is lost, and you don't necessarily have the quads strength to absorb the shock when you come down from a rebound.
Really, at this point, that sort of advice is all we have. There are no braces that are preventive. There are proprioceptive exercises that most colleges and pro teams have their players do. At the recreational level, these exercises aren't normally taught.
What's the prognosis for an athlete with an ACL tear?
Dr. Souryal: This used to be a devastating injury. When an ACL tears, it does not heal. Unlike most other ligaments, the ACL never has the opportunity to mend due to its position and role in the knee -- it's very much like a rubber band. That's why this is a forever kind of injury. It used to end athletic participation both on the professional and recreational level. Now with arthroscopic surgery and proper strengthening and rehabilitation techniques, the future is much brighter. National results show a 96 to 98 percent return to sport. Recovery still takes six months and is economically demanding and involves an operation, but it's no longer career-ending.
Dr. Souryal (Email Policy)
Texas Sports Medicine and Orthopaedic Group Home Page